His
Majesty reminded the members of the lhengye zhungtsho that the Constitution
of the kingdom of Bhutan was drafted with a single-minded focus that attached
the highest importance to creating a democratic political system best suited
to Bhutan. "The adoption of the Constitution will provide the legal framework
for a democratic political system that is best suited for Bhutan
and will establish a system of governance that will safeguard the
security and sovereignty of the nation and ensure the well being of the
Bhutanese people for all time to come," said His Majesty the King.
His
Majesty shared his perceptions and views on the draft Constitution, which
has 34 Articles, explaining their significance and emphasising the
need for all Bhutanese people to understand their implications in the right
perspective.
His
Majesty said that Article II, on the institution of Monarchy, aimed
to ensure that, if Bhutan had a good and capable King, he would be able
to serve the country and the people meaningfully and ensure that the national
interests were safeguarded and the aspirations of the people fulfilled.
At the same time, if a King did not have the capability or the commitment
to discharge this sacred responsibility, he would not be able to compromise
the interests of the nation and the people.
His
Majesty expressed his satisfaction with the comprehensive rights and
responsibilities prescribed for the Bhutanese people in the Constitution.
His
Majesty the King also emphasised the importance of the National Council as one of the houses of parliament. With 20 members elected directly
by the people in the 20 dzongkhags and five eminent persons nominated by
the King, the National Council would act as a house of review on matters
concerning the sovereignty of the country and the interests of the people
that needed to be brought to the notice of the King, the prime minister,
and the National Assembly. His Majesty explained that, while such a body
was called an "Upper House" in some parliamentary systems and the
National Assembly would be the "Lower House", these terms could
carry the wrong nuances in the perception of the Bhutanese people.
His
Majesty emphasised the importance of the Constitutional posts for parliamentary
democracy to be a success. Unlike countries where the persons holding Constitutional
positions were appointed by a King, President, or Prime Minister, thus
compromising their objectivity, the positions in Bhutan would be nominated
jointly by the Prime Minister, the Chief Justice, Speaker of the National
Assembly, the chairperson of the National Council, and the opposition leader for appointment by the King.
His
Majesty the King said that the issue of political parties had been
thoroughly debated during the drafting process. Multi party systems in other countries were studied carefully and it was felt that in Bhutan
there was every possibility that each dzongkhag might establish a political
party which would not be conducive to political stability and might
affect the success of democracy in Bhutan. The concept of a three-party
system had also been considered. While a three-party system had advantages,
there was a risk that the parties could become regionalized, leading to
communal discord and problems. In a three-party system, the party winning
the largest number of votes could also be relegated as the opposition
party if the other two combined to form the government.
His
Majesty pointed out that the government would fully fund the political
parties through the Election Commission to ensure the integrity
of the electoral process in Bhutan.
His
Majesty also pointed out to the members of the lhengye zhungtsho that there had been some concerns on the administrative structure and functions
of local governments. The Constitution had, therefore, made a provision
for parliament to regulate the powers and functions of the dzongda and
local governments to ensure that local governments would be self reliant
and self sustaining.
His
Majesty the King said that he was aware of the widespread opinion that
Bhutan was not ready for democracy and that it was too early to enact the
Constitution. His Majesty himself had been personally informed by ministers,
officials, members of the business community, the clergy, and the people
about the concerns that a government formed by political parties would
not work because of the lack of political experience, the absence of the
necessary institutions, and their inability to provide stable and good
governance.
His
Majesty said that, while it was natural for people to have misgivings and
the concerns were also genuine, it was important to understand the political
changes in the perspective of the current situation. Bhutan, through good
fortune and fate, could not hope for a better moment than now for this
historical development and would never find another opportunity like this.
Today the
King, government, and the people in all sections of society, enjoyed a
level of trust and fidelity that had never been seen before. The security
of the country was ensured and the people enjoyed peace and stability.
The genuine rapport in Bhutan's relations with India had reached a new
height. With the commissioning of the Tala Hydro Electric Project within
two years, the greatly enhanced revenue would bring major economic benefits
for the government and the people. Bhutan also enjoyed close relations
with its development partners as well as other countries that appreciated
the kingdom's wholesome policies for development and change.
It
was a most auspicious time for the Constitution to be enacted. Unlike other
countries where Constitutions were drafted during difficult times, under
pressure from political influences and interests, Bhutan was fortunate
that the change came under no pressure or compulsion but at a time when
the country enjoyed unprecedented peace and stability with total harmony
and abiding fidelity between the King, the government, and the people.
While
people questioned the process of parliamentary democracy being introduced
too early, it should be understood that the Bhutanese people would never
gain political experience until they took part in the new political system.
Bhutan today had the luxury of nurturing democracy to maturity and solving
all problems at an early stage in the democratic experience. While problems
were always inevitable in the early stages of a new political process,
all problems at this stage could be resolved without harming the interests
of the nation and people.
His
Majesty reminded the members of the lhengye zhungtsho that Bhutan had laid
sound foundations for a genuinely workable democracy at all levels of society.
The dzongkhag yargye tshogdu had 24 years of experience in decentralisation,
the geog yargye tshogchung had been established 14 years ago, and the elected
council of ministers had exercised full executive authority for seven years.
His
Majesty the King also reminded the members of the lhengye zhungtsho that
the essence of Bhutan's success in the past 30 years had been the ability
to anticipate challenges and pre-empt problems. Bhutan had drawn up the
right national policies, aims and objectives, and plans, all at strategic
moments, in the process of development.
Therefore
the same with democracy. The Constitution introduced an important phase
of trial and experimentation with democratic government. Bhutan's lack
of experience in democratic governance would not result in political instability
and problems. The people, politicians, officials, and the system would
get valuable experience and exposure.
His
Majesty informed the members of the lhengye zhungtsho that he would personally
conduct the consultations with the people on the draft Constitution. Having widely distributed the draft to the people in the 20 dzongkhags,
His Majesty would meet the people as and when they were ready. The consultations
would be held chronologically based on the feedback from the dzongkhags.
His
Majesty said that it was important for the Chhoetse Penlop, Jigme Khesar
Namgyel Wangchuck, to be involved in the consultations with the people,
to interact with them, and to understand their views and perceptions on
the Constitution. His Majesty said that it would be the Chhoetse Penlop's
responsibility to implement and uphold the Constitution.
His
Majesty pointed out that the draft Constitution was not submitted to the National
Assembly first because the people might not accept the decisions of
the Assembly as there would be only 100 chimis representing the dzongkhags.
The Constitution of Bhutan would, therefore, be adopted by referendum,
as has been the practice in Bhutan for all important issues, and then enacted
in the National Assembly.
His
Majesty the King expressed his appreciation to the 39-member Constitution
drafting committee which was established in November, 2001. The committee,
chaired by the Chief Justice with the Speaker of the National Assembly
as a member, included two representatives of the ecclesiastical bodies,
one elected member from each of the 20 dzongkhags, the Zhung Kalyon and
all the members of the Royal Advisory Council, five representatives of
the government, and three lawyers of the High Court.
Although
they had no previous experience the committee had worked hard to draft
the Constitution. In the process of drafting the Constitution the committee
had studied the Constitutions of more than 50 other countries. The idea
was not to copy other Constitutions but to study and adopt what was good
and relevant for Bhutan. His Majesty also expressed his appreciation to
the council of ministers for their contribution. His Majesty said that
the Constitution was not a gift from the King to the people but it was
the responsibility of all sections of the Bhutanese people to draft a Constitution
which would be relevant and beneficial for Bhutan. |